Loading... Please wait...
Free Shipping on all orders of $40 or more nationwide
  • Image 1
  • Image 2

Original Penuche


Product Description

The purest fudge we make consisting of just four simple ingredients: Cabot butter, cane sugar, milk, and pure honey. With a deeply satisfying caramel flavor, this original penuche fudge is most similar to the original Scottish family recipe.

This penuche fudge is one of our most popular flavors because it's uniquely rich and smooth. Just think, you can have this Mill Fudge Factory specialty delivered right to your door, or surprise someone you love!

Product Reviews

Write Review

Previous | Showing reviews 11-20 of 28 | Next

  1. penuche

    Posted by Ruth Worthen Whittier on 4th Apr 2019

    My mother always loved penuche fudge and that is why I love it today. I just purchased 10 slices of penuche fudge with a colored festive bow and I will give the fudge as gifts to family and friends. Delicious, creamy, lots of flavor and attractive. Thank you.

  2. Fantastic fudge

    Posted by Deb on 19th Aug 2017

    Homemade and melt in your mouth fudge!

  3. a good penuche

    Posted by tom on 2nd Feb 2017

    It's hard to find a fudge maker that has any idea what penuche fudge is. I was very disappointed in a five-star retailer on Amazon as I got what amounted to a plain vanilla, not penuche. Classic penuche should have that butter-scotchy brown-sugary taste. Another retailer I found on eBay, although the price was right, was also way off. Vermont Country Store sells a decent penuche, and so this place, The Mill Fudge Factory (TMFF). The TMFF version is more caramelized, crumbly and slightly less buttery. The Vermont Country Store version is more creamy, flowery and buttery. Both are pretty good.


    Posted by Peggy Houdek on 25th Apr 2016

    For several years, my husband sent me fudge from Mill Fudge Factory for special occasions. My favorite quickly became Penuche. Tried others, but always came back to Penuche. It's just the best. My husband passed away a few months ago, so I decided to continue the tradition and get myself fudge for special occasions. Why not!!

  5. Delicious

    Posted by Lisa Dawson on 27th Mar 2015

    Penuche fudge that is made properly (with correct flavor) is hard to find...yours is delicious. Thank you.

  6. Just yum!

    Posted by Unknown on 17th Feb 2015

    When I took my first bite of this fudge, my eyes literally rolled into the back of my head it was so good. Thank you for making such a great product!

  7. Wonderful fudge

    Posted by Kim on 6th Jan 2015

    I bought this fudge because my mother said she hadn't had penuche fudge in years. It was a rich and luxurious fudge--well worth the price. She said she doesn't remember fudge tasting this good. In my next order, I will be sure to get some for myself as well.

  8. Just like I remember. . .

    Posted by Catherine, Fort Lauderdale on 8th Dec 2014

    Creamy. Enough sweet to be savory and leave you wanting just another quick taste. Thick. Just yummy. So like days gone by.

  9. This Penuche Should Win a Fudge of the World Award

    Posted by Janice Girardi (Bali, Indonesia) on 13th Nov 2014

    I think this should win a fudge of the world award, seriously. I consider myself to be a fudge connoisseur, and this one wins the prize!


    Posted by Margaret Houdek (Lenox, MA) on 13th Nov 2014

    I LOVE the Penuche. Fudge has always been my favorite candy, but usually, it's not good. This is perfect! I will continue to order regularly. Also like the chocolate and maple, but Penuche is the best.

Previous | Showing reviews 11-20 of 28 | Next

Find Similar Products by Category